today vs Motion: the case for planning your own day vs. letting AI plan it
What Motion and today are fundamentally doing
Motion is an AI-powered calendar that automatically schedules your tasks and meetings into available time slots, optimizing for deadlines and priorities. You input tasks and their requirements; Motion fills your calendar. Today takes the opposite approach: you create each time block intentionally, decide the day's outcome, and plan around your calendar rather than having the calendar planned for you. The philosophical difference is significant — Motion automates planning decisions to save time; today treats planning decisions as deliberate cognitive acts that shape how you work, not overhead to eliminate.
What Motion does better than today
Motion excels at deadline-driven scheduling: if you have multiple tasks with hard deadlines across multiple projects, Motion's AI optimization ensures the most important things get time without you having to manually calculate priority and sequence. For users managing complex project portfolios with many interdependencies and tight deadlines, automatic scheduling reduces the cognitive overhead of capacity planning significantly. Motion also handles rescheduling automatically when meetings run over or new tasks arrive — it adjusts the rest of the day's plan rather than requiring you to manually do so.
What today does better than Motion
Today's manual planning creates something Motion's automation can't: intentional commitment to your day's direction. When you choose your daily outcome and create each block deliberately, you're making an explicit cognitive investment in the day's direction. That investment changes how you work — you're executing a plan you made, not following a schedule an algorithm generated. Today also tracks how your day actually went (session logs, energy data, reflection) in a way that Motion doesn't, creating a feedback loop for continuous improvement. For users whose primary challenge is focus and intentionality rather than deadline complexity, today's deliberate approach produces better results.
Which tool fits which type of worker
Motion works best for deadline-dense roles: project managers coordinating many deliverables, attorneys managing case deadlines, operations managers with complex task dependencies. Today works best for deep-work-centric roles: software engineers, writers, researchers, and anyone whose primary challenge is protecting focused time for cognitively demanding work. Many Motion users report that the AI scheduling is accurate but the planned day feels foreign — you didn't choose the sequence, so following it feels less like executing your own plan and more like following someone else's instructions. That psychological ownership of the plan matters for execution quality.
Frequently asked questions
Related
- Comparisontoday vs Todoist: Daily Planner vs. Task Managertoday is a daily planning app focused on time blocks and focus sessions. Todoist is a full-featured task manager. Here's what each does best and when to use both.
- Comparisontoday vs Sunsama: Minimalism vs. Full Daily Planning SuiteSunsama is a comprehensive daily planner with channel integrations, time estimation, and guided rituals. today is a focused, quiet daily planner. Here's how they compare.
- Comparisontoday vs Reclaim.ai: Habit Scheduling vs. Daily PlanningReclaim.ai automatically protects time for habits and tasks in your calendar using AI. today is a manual daily planner with session tracking. Here's how they compare.
- Comparisontoday vs Google Calendar: Daily Planning Beyond the CalendarGoogle Calendar shows you when things happen. today helps you plan what to do with the time between them. Here's what a dedicated daily planner adds beyond a calendar.